Orthodox attitudes to gay people shift

Dan82 · Aug 9, 2010

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2010/aug/09/gay-orthodox-judaism-rabbis

If you think the Christian world has a problem with gay people, you should try orthodox Judaism. For centuries homosexuality has been taboo; it's not what nice Jewish boys or girls do. The biblical proscription against "men lying with men as though with a woman" (Leviticus 20:13) is considered the very bedrock of Jewish morality. For traditional Judaism marriage is the highest state of social bonding – a true union of body and soul. Despite some odd exceptions in biblical and rabbinical literature, (Jeremiah is told by God to stay single, Ben Azzai, one of the greatest of the Mishnaic teachers, remains a bachelor by choice), even celibacy was frowned upon. Part of this opposition was no doubt based on a response to the cultural environment – pagan in the biblical era, Christian in the rabbinic one. But despite major shifts in sociological contexts, the ban against homosexuality was rigidly enforced throughout the centuries. Whilst in other areas the rabbis often showed great flexibility and understanding, this particular area remained off-limits.

In recent years, however, homosexuality, among even the most Orthodox sectors of Judaism, has become a growing feature of contemporary Jewish life. In both America and Israel – the world's two largest Jewish communities – it has not been uncommon for rabbis and others to "come out", often suffering the consequences that such a confession entails. Moreover, reports of homosexual relations between rabbi-teachers and their students have been a regular feature of news items in both communities. In Israel and the US these behaviours have been the subject of a number of feature and documentary films.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/belief/2010/aug/09/gay-orthodox-judaism-rabbis
Click to expand...

slightlysane · Aug 10, 2010

My experience with orthodox persons hasn't been great in that area. Perhaps I've just been unlucky though. None of them knew I was gay to be fair but it seemed much of their humour was homophobic and a few used the fact that reform Judaism permits gay marriage as an argument to promote Orthodoxy. Anyway, just sharing my experience, hope others have had better ones.

Orthodox attitudes to gay people shift

Dan82
Full Member

slightlysane
Regular Member

Orthodox attitudes to gay people shift

Thread Tools

Dan82 Full Member

slightlysane Regular Member

Dan82
Full Member

slightlysane
Regular Member